TNT Post vs PostNL: Testing the first rebranding effects
As TNT announced in it’s press release on the 7th of April:
“Our new name PostNL symbolises the reliability and down to earth approach of our company. This name does justice to our past, something we are very proud of. By the same token we emphasise that we are a true Dutch company, with ambitions that go beyond mail and operations that reach beyond our borders. Our three-sided logo symbolises the heart of our company, with mail, parcels and e-commerce at the core.”
TNT Post through a foreigner’s eyes.
As a foreigner, who has been living in the Netherlands for almost five years I can tell that the orange Royal crown logo of TNT | Post has been quite an iconic brand for me. A logo that has welcomed me every time I was receiving a parcel with delicious goodies from my Greek grandmother or postcards and mails from my friends all around the globe. Besides the weird name that reminded me more of Wile E. Coyote than of a post office, I had start to love and trust the brand.
So, I thought this was a great opportunity to test how the new logo scores and how do people really perceive it, so we can see beyond the usual flamboyant press releases.
Testing the two logos
To get a first impression of how do people perceive the two logos I set a quick Usabilla test. Through Twitter I recruited 47 participants. In the test I asked participants to click on the three words they think that characterizes each logo the best (out of 18 words in total).
Comparing the two logos
Analyzing the results, the TNT | Post logo is considered by most as a boring logo, but also a serious and professional one. The crown, a strong Dutch symbol, inspires reliability and responsibility, as some of the participants noted.
“They don’t have a crown in their logo for nothing…”
(Responsible) Because of the crown! They have a Dutch symbol in it so they need to be responsible otherwise they wouldn’t have it.
On the other hand, the PostNL logo scored very high as a modern and friendly logo, but also a fussy one. Looking back at the press release, where TNT states:
“Our new name PostNL symbolises the reliability and down to earth approach of our company.”
“(Loud) i think the orange faded background is a little nasty and over the top”
“(Ugly) to me this does not say ‘post’, i wish i could explain it further”
“Weird (just the triangle-like shape)”
“I don’t mean modern in a good way, i mean modern like trying too hard i do like the font choice”
” (Loud) Too big. Background color is taking over the text”
It’s always very exciting to see the effects of big rebranding efforts from huge institutions like the Dutch postal service for instance. The TNT | post was an established logo that certainly had an equity and an important place in the Dutch visual landscape. It didn’t excite people, but did inspire trust and reliability. Essential factors for a postal service. Now, the new logo carries over the orange color, the crown, and the lowercase typography. But with the three-pointed holding shape tries to become friendlier and more modern. The typography is a good evolution from the old one, however dressing it up in shading and placing an unfortunate stroke around it makes the logo weaker and fussier. In the end, both logos scored almost the same, and now we only have to wait how the new logo will fare in contrast to the familiar TNT Express fleet and packages that will still roam the world.
What do you think? Share your opinion at the comments thread below ;)
Enjoyed the post? Why don’t you retweet it?